Loging in as a member revokes access to 'visitor' public pages

Hello, I've setup a few subscription levels and when I purchase a membership level and login, I am no long able to access public or visitor pages (contact us, about us, etc.). How do I make it so that these common pages are accessible? I'd prefer not to have to individually add these pages one by one (using positive and negative rules) onto every single access level.

Right now I'm using URL Groups and have placed all my content that I want protected under parent pages that are entered into URL Groups. That all seems to be working except that it's blocking everything else.

Thank you, I look forward to your reply.