MailChimp Doesn't Show Subscribers, but the Download does(?)

I have the mailchimp integration on my site and set to auto-enroll a new user to a list.

In my MailChimp account, it shows "5 subscribers", but when I click on the overview it says "Sorry, you don't have any subscribers".

However, when I download the list to CSV, all users are there... What's the deal?