Members assigned ACTIVE memberships when payment isn't completed

Okay, I posted an issue prior to the latest update (actually it might've been a couple updates ago) where members that showed a "pending" payment but never completed the payment were assigned an expired membership with no expiration and no payment:

https://premium.wpmudev.org/forums/topic/members-assigned-expired-memberships-when-payment-isnt-completed#post-897156

I am experiencing the exact same issue now except it is assigning ACTIVE memberships to those that aren't completing payment. They DO NOT have access to protected content, their account is treated as if they never paid, which is good, but now if they WANT TO ACTUALLY PAY it shows them as having an active membership. This is causing confusion for a lot of our clients. I'd appreciate any support, these problems are getting ridiculous. Support Access is ready to go.

Thanks,
Tim