Membership 2 Plugin and https redirect issue

I just installed an SSL and my site is now https. I have the membership 2 pro feature and you have to login for the entire site.

However, when you go to the site, the redirect shows http if you go to http://inside.preferredship.com -- https://inside.preferredship.com/protected-content/?redirect_to=http%3A%2F%2Finside.preferredship.com%2F --

Is this an issue I can resolve in the plugin or is this an issue with how I have my site redirecting?