Membership 2 Pro not protecting any content

Why is our blog showing when Membership 2 Pro should be protecting it? In fact, no matter what we try to protect with your Membership software it DOES NOT WORK. We used the simple default member which was seemed like a great solution for us. We applauded the simplicity of the install and setup and loved the ability to test as a member. Unfortunately the plugin is not protecting the content as follows;

Setup correctly as follows;

https://www.evernote.com/l/AVzsN_yEAjdLz6MW7xuybxhA_oGwNm8IRJY

NO PROTECTION as follows;

https://www.evernote.com/l/AVw5c8EydvJOM6ozZMovDBZoAuBF53Hlz0s

Pleas advise ASAP. Thank you