Membership 2 Pro upgrade broke the registration process

I followed the instructions to upgrade from Protected Content to Membership 2 Pro. It seems to be mostly working except when a new user clicks on the Register link, it takes them directly to the BuddyPress registration page, whereas before with Protected Content, they would have to choose a membership subscription first and then it would go to the Buddypress registration page.

How can I fix this please?
(P.S. Support Access is turned on)