Joe...my Monthly subscribers received a mass email to renew their Membership. In Communications the email was set to be sent 5 days prior to renewal date. It has caused alot of confusion for my Members...since they signed up in Paypal for a Serial renewal subscription every 30 days. I did not disable the plugin, I disabled the email in Communications section. Until you have another suggestion on how to code the renewal email to only be sent to those whose subscriptions are actually ending, I had to set the days to zero so it would not send.