Membership not protecting content

I've got a new page on that I want to protect so that only logged in members can see it.

When I used the short code, [level-staff-access] [/level-staff-access] the shortcodes are visible, so I went back into the access rules and added the page to the list of pages only available to logged in members.

Now, logged in members can't access the form, while the general public can.

Can anyone help me troubleshoot this? I'm sure it's something dumb I'm missing.

Thanks -