Membership or Marketpress for Donations?

Howdy everyone,

I am launching my new site today (, and glad to have phase I development complete! That said phase II is starting, and has one item that is leaving me stumped due to the overwhelming number of options. (I guess that is a good problem to have)

I need to incorporate a flexible donations component that would either allow folks to donate once, or donate through a monthly or annual subscription. I am looking at the below options currently; however, I would like to hear any other suggestions.


I know I have read about folks using external links to enable subscriptions in Marketpress, and the plugin is of course friendly to one time donations.


Excellent subscription capability, and added flexibility in the future for restricted/ enhanced content. I do not see one time donations supported with Membership.