Membership plugin blocking entire site

I downloaded it and set it up about a week or so ago, and it was working great. Then there was an update available, so I updated it. After the update our home page became protected content. Nothing was changed in the plugin...it just did it on it's own. I've gone over all of the settings in the plugin and verified that the homepage is set correctly in the "reading" portion of the settings. Patrick from support suggested a few things, but none of those were it. I need someone to login and check it out. Thanks!