Membership says everyone is already a member

Help!

I've installed Membership with two access levels: Visitor (ie anyone who visits the site, no login required) and Member ($4.95 subscription for access to certain content).

It's letting people register but then telling them they already have a subscription.

Try it out here: http://peachesmag.com/join-the-erotica-club/

I've uninstalled the plugins that I installed after Membership so there shouldn't be a conflict there...

HELP. :slight_smile:

Palmer