Membership: Studio Theme - Main Menu won't show up in header unless logged in

No matter what I do, the Main Menu wont show up in the header on my home page unless I'm logged -in as a user. I have tried everything!

I even deactivated the membership plug-in, deleted all of the membership levels and subscriptions and tried again. No matter what I do the toolbar wont show up for the "stranger account" from the home page. I show's up fine an all the other pages.

I'm using the Studio Theme. I've scoured through the code for buth the default template and the main page template and there seems to be no difference in the code. Any Ideas?