Membership URL Groups and Buddypress

Hello Guys

I've the membership plugin working with my multi-site and Buddypress. For the visitors (ie no subscription plan) I want them to be able to see the /members/ page that buddypress creates for displaying the members loop, but when the visitor clicks on a person in the members list, rather than seeing the persons profile they see the protected content.

My thoughts on this is to use URL Groups.

So I setup a Group with Page URL set to :*

Strip query strings from URL - NO
Regular Expression - YES

this works to protect the members profiles, but it also protects the /members/ page too.

Have I got it wrong?