Memberships Not redirecting from PayPal to Welcome Page

Hello,

After someone registers and buys a membership for the first time, we want them to redirect from paypal to the welcome page, but instead its going to the protected content page (which just looks bad lol). Can you help me diagnose this issue? We are using login redirect plugin, could that be the problem? I have the page option in the options panel set to "Welcome". Please advise.