Multisite Privacy Plugin Issues

Hello, I'm using the domain mapping plugin, as well as, the Multisite Privacy plugin on AccidentAttorneys.org. Everything has been working fine until this morning.

I created a new site http://jeffersoncity.accidentattorneys.org/ and had the site defaulting to private. However, when I clicked the "Allow search engines to index this site" button to make this site public (and saved), nothing happened. The site is still showing the login screen.

I've tried purging Varnish on my server and clearing the cache on CloudFlare. It doesn't appear to be a cacheing problem.

To test the plugin more, I tried making another sites, http://greeley.accidentattorneys.org/, private. However, I am still able to access that site.

I tried toggling the sites back-and-forth and disabling the plugin. Any other thoughts as to why this Plugin seems to have stopped working?

Thanks for your time!