My multisite doesn't create new sites without remove email verification plugin

Hi,
I recently installed the remove email verification plugin. Unfortunately it still sends the verification email and also provides a different password than the one the user set when signing up. I deleted the plugin and then my multisite stopped creating new sites upon sign up.

When I reactivated the plugin, the sites were being created again...so I left it activated until this gets sorted out. My questions are:

1. I would like my site to run without this plugin, what changed?

2. If that's not going to work, is there a way to remove the automatically generated password from showing up?

Thank you