New Blog Template Not Being Applied After Update

Since updating plugin to v.1.9.1 our templat is not being applied to new blogs. The Twenty Thirteen theme is being used with none of the settings or content from the template.

We do not allow selection of templates during signup. We have one template blog in the list of blog templates and it is set as the default.

I just confirmed settings and re-saved template.

Site is if anyone cares to create a site to test.

Otherwise, any suggestions?