New users do not get auto assigned a group and have all access blocked

When I create a new user to my wordpress account, as soon as I log in with them I get "The content you are trying to access is only available to members. Sorry." on every page, including the home page. The user is not put into a default member group, and although there are no restricting member groups created they are restricted from every link I click on, even though they are still all viewable.