Non member not getting restricted area page

I'm using the WordPress Membership plugin on a test site: http://www.virtualstaffschool.com

I'm having an issue with my New Visitor level.

I have placed a button on the Member Area page that goes to the Member Category.

If logged in, the member goes to the Member Category.

If not logged in, it goes to a blank page. The "Protected Content" page is activated but isn't called up when the New Visitor tries to access the Member Category page.