Not seeing FB or G+ icons in Pay with a Like

Hey folks,

I'm not seeing Pay with a Like buttons. I get only a text-link to Twitter; nothing for Facebook, LinkedIn (though I'd normally have it off), or G+.

The excerpt is working fine, and the Twitter text-link works when clicked, but no buttons. I've killed all sharing options in my theme, and tried deactivating each of the services in the PwaL settings; still nothing.

I'm also having problems with Events + shortcodes using another theme from the same developer (Organic Themes), which seems to be true across their themes (https://premium.wpmudev.org/forums/topic/event-countdown-shortcode). Maybe it's something in conflict with their framework?

The plugin's currently shut off, because otherwise I'd just be crippling my site. Happy to turn it back on, or PM a login to an authenticated Jedi.

Any ideas? Thanks!