Pro Sites won't add new site after payment

I'm using stripe in test mode, and after submitting the payement form I get the "Your payment was successful message" with a link to the dashboard. But trying to visit the dashboard just goes back to the checkout page where it tells me the account is unpaid - although the subscription due date is moved up a month. With Pay to blog enabled (I would like to use it) it says the account is unpaid and won't let me in. With it disabled, I get to the dashboard and the Pro Sites link is in the state it would be if the site wasn't yet a pro site.

Any ideas on how to fix this?