Pay With a Like - Content Not Revealed

Hi guys -

Pay With a Like isn't working for me on speaksheets.com (WP 3.4). On the home page, I have a bit of content hidden via Selection Tool method. I can share via the methods, but then nothing happens - no content is revealed.

I want to run a Thesis child theme from KolaKube, but have downgraded to Twenty Eleven to see if its a theme conflict, and neither themes work.

Here's what I've selected via the Selection Tool:

[pwal id="11220800" description="Download the 12 Language Cheat Sheet With a Like!"]Link to 12 Language Cheat Sheet here. (if not live yet, just email info@speaksheets.com)[/pwal]

Thoughts? Thanks!