Pay With a Like displaying locked content w/o liking first!

We just purchased the "Pay with a Like" plugin, installed it, and it's not working. We adjusted all the setting multiple times...but our locked content continues to display in the front end without liking/sharing it first. The social media buttons are NOT display what so ever.
Here's the link to the page where we are trying to use it (test server):

NEED HELP ASAP. Trying to launch site by Monday.