Protect Content blog page error


I am having problems with the content being displayed on my "Library" page with this plugin activated, which is my blog page on the website I am developing. When I am logged in it appears normally as the "Library" home blog page with the content and sidebar. Every other page works like normal except for the "Library" page. When I am logged out it says "Account" in my page title area on the "Library" page and at the bottom of each post it says "you must be logged in to view this page", except I didn't protect the "Library" page. And the sidebar is gone as well.
In other words, I don't have any content protected yet, just testing it out with one membership level set up and it is throwing this error.

I will also grant you access to be able to check it out.