Protected Content Does Not Protect Content

If you goto this site and look at the menu you will not see GIFT SHOP on the menu. This is the protected content page. If you sign up , then the menu item is shown. So far so good.

However, if you are not logged in / registered and you know the path to the menu item:

then you can see the page that I wanted protected. I reported this bug a few weeks back and then I received this cheerful but unsettling email from the support team:

"We've improved the protection logic to recognize WooCommerce correctly.
I've tested it and it looks all very good and stable now, so please give a try! It's so much more stable and better than the older versions."

So I installed it and gave it a try. AND, drum roll please....

It still does not work.

Please advise....