Protected Content functioning backwards for Custom Post Types

So I have a single membership set up and have no "Protect Custom Post Types" selected. However when nothing is selected, my EventOn plugin does not show to visitors. When I select the EventOn custom post type to be "Protected" it only shows up to visitors and administrators, not subscribers. No matter what, it wont just show up for ALL users which is what I want it to do. The site can be seen at bit.ly/17qUIph

I have WPMU dashboard and have authorized support to get this resolved ASAP. Thanks