Protected content page not working

I tried to search for this but all the answers were over a year ago. I set up the membership site with visitors option to see basic content. The buddypress portion of the site I wanted to be protected content. When the member is clicked as a visitor it comes up a 404 error page not the protected content page. Since only visitors are restricted I used negative rules. I think I followed instructions correctly.

The site is going to launch tomorrow evening so I don’t have any more time to play with it. I finally put the menu item for members in the negative section of the visitors and it took it out of the menu for visitors. Not exactly what I wanted as its important for visitors to actually “see” a membership area on the menu they can’t access because they aren’t members.

Can anyone help me with this?