Protected content plugin: post not showing up.

Hey whats up!

Hope this find you well. I am using the protected content plugin on and seem to be having an issue with post showing up when I tag them with the "premium" category. One thing to keep in mind that it shows up fine for logged in users who have proper access, but the post does not show up for non logged in users. The other thing to note is that if I tag it was another category of kkets say "MLB" along with the premium tag, it shows up for no logged in users and is also no longer protected. I have included a screen shot showing a logged in user and a non logged in user.

Is there something I need to enable in order for non logged in users to see the post, but when they click on it for it to redirect them to log in to their account ( this page - - )