I have seen this issue on several other forum titles since June of 2010. Some of the forums just stop. I can assume they found their own fix or they walked away and requested a refund. I can't seem to find an answer. When I downloaded the lite version of the membership plugin, it redirected fine. I upgraded to the full membership plugin to add additional levels and now the redirect no longer works.
My site is public and allows for free memberships. The protected page link is
I get a 404 message instead of my protected content page which is...
I've tested on Chrome and Safari.
I have included a screenshot of my membership options to show you my settings.