Protected Content Sections Not Showing to Logged in Users

Hi, hope all is well.

After updating to membership 2 pro, and importing members from WPMU, I am having some trouble seeing certain pages. I currently have the protection rules for all pages set so that 'everyone' has access, but some pages are saying "protected content" and giving me the login screen. What's strange is that even when I login with a registered account, I am taken to the same login page with the protected content message. Do you know why this might be or how I can get these pages to be viewable again?

Please let me know if you need me to elaborate on anything.