Recent Posts Widget Works, but Plugin does not?

I am using the Global Posts plugin. I checked my database, and it is working.

I am using the Recent Global Posts Widget - it works flawlessly.

I am using the Recent Global Posts Plugin - so that I could display the Recent global posts to my homepage. It displays recent posts, but they are different than what the widget displays. The plugin is not displaying the most recent posts.

My site is - it looks messed up, the appearance is not the issue I am working on right now. It is the functionality of the plugin.