Registration Page on Single Membership Plugin not working

Need help on another site with another plugin. I have the Membership Plugin: v2.0.2 installed on a wordpress single site: v3.1.2. I have set up one group called Clients who will be able to access a special area with resources only available to our clients. The gateway is set to "Free Subscriptions" and is active. Membership plugin has been set to enable.

When you try to register it takes you to the registration page but starts on Option 2? And doesn't show all the options underneath or a way to go back to Option 1. Any help appreciated!