Registration redirect does not go to welcome page

I've gone through videos, documentation, and another forum post and still don't get the user to be redirected to the "Welcome" page (http://stevensvilleadventistchurch.org/welcome) after they complete registration.
- Registration completed page is set to the "welcome" page
- After registration, they are placed in a "friends" subscription
- After their application is reviewed, I can move them to a "members" subscription

I've checked tables and repaired tables. I can't figure this issue out.