Registration redirect does not go to welcome page

I've gone through videos, documentation, and another forum post and still don't get the user to be redirected to the "Welcome" page ( after they complete registration.
- Registration completed page is set to the "welcome" page
- After registration, they are placed in a "friends" subscription
- After their application is reviewed, I can move them to a "members" subscription

I've checked tables and repaired tables. I can't figure this issue out.