Removing Pro Sites Status

I need to manually remove the Pro Sites status for a user and allow them to access their site indefinitely. When I remove the Pro Site status for a site, the user can no longer log into their site.

Step 1: Go to Pro Sites Management and Remove Pro Sites Status for client's site
- Log will say "Pro Site status has been withdrawn."

Step 2: Log into site (subdomain.domain.com/login)

Expected Results: User is logged in and directed to /wp-admin
Actual Results: User is re-directed to /login page