shortcodes not working on membership plugin

So I have a membership level called 'members'. I am trying to use a shortcode at the bottom of my pages to hide content.

I am using different browsers for testing -- yes, I'm not logged in with the browser I'm testing.

I tried two different shortcodes

(I tried this because I found the documentation is confusing.) Both versions show up in the content for visitors:

You can see the shortcodes displayed underneath the youtube videos.

This is a brand new install of Membership and I really don't want to go back to S2. :slight_frown: