Sidebar in Products List page

I am trying to keep the same sidebar on the store front page across the product list, categories, product detail view, etc. Unable to find where to set this up. It changes from page to page. Please help! I need to get this fixed asap.

Here is the site: http://likemelighthouse.org, please click on LIKEME Gear from the main nav and you'll see what I'm experiencing.

Thanks,

Howard