Signups redirects to signin

So I have been having some issues setting up the directory plugin so I decided to try installing it on a completely clean version of wordpress with no other plugins installed and using the default theme. I have it all set up, but when I try to sign up it just redirects me to the signin page. I have Paypal sandbox mode set up in the system, but I also tried it with free listings. So far no go. I also noticed that when I set it up on my original site, it added 2 user types "Member Paid" and "Member Not Paid" but it did not add those user types this time. The screenshot is where I ended up when I clicked the "Signup" button. Thoughts? Thanks!