Simple Ads Showing Up Error

This Plugin seems so easy yet I am having a small issue with the display.

Have selected only after post. See Screenshot.

And that is working as it should, yet it also displays at the bottom of each Subsites/Pages?

http://lucidhive.com/mr-right/
http://lucidhive.com/mr-right/2014/06/25/118/

Why would this be happenign when I clearly dont select the Page Option?

Thanks