Site disabled even though it's paid

We have a site that paid but the site says it's disabled (http://coconinobasketball.com/). Here's what Pro Sites says:

Modify Site : Coconino High Basketball - Official Site (Site ID: 95)
Expired Pro Site

Pro Site priviledges expired on: January 10, 2012
Previous Level: 1 - Silver
Previous Payment Gateway: Trial
Previous Payment Term: 12 Month

Subscription Information
Subscription Description: AmericanYouth.com Silver: $***.00 USD every 12 months
PayPal Profile ID: I-************
Payment Method: Their PayPal Account
Last Payment Date: January 10, 2012
Next Payment Date: January 10, 2013
Payments Made With This Subscription: 1 *
Aggregate Total With This Subscription: $***.00 *

Account History:
2012-01-10 6:09:54 pm Pro Site status has been withdrawn.
2012-01-09 8:30:40 pm User modifying subscription via PayPal Express: PayPal returned an error: The token is invalid
2012-01-09 8:30:39 pm User modifying subscription via PayPal Express: PayPal returned an error: The token is invalid
2012-01-09 8:30:38 pm Reminder to cancel previous Trial subscription sent to *********@yahoo.com
2012-01-09 8:30:37 pm User modifying subscription via PayPal Express: New subscription created (AmericanYouth.com Silver: $***.00 USD every 12 months), first payment will be made on January 10, 2012 - I-************
2011-12-19 4:43:57 am Pro Site status expiration extended until January 19, 2012.
2011-12-19 12:42:07 am Pro Site status has been withdrawn.

We *did* get paid. The "Subscription Information" seems to make it seem like it should be valid but it's showing as expired.