Strange Pagination Issues

We are starting to paginate some of our posts, such as this one: http://www.encapo.com/top/15-organizing-products-on-amazon-that-people-actually-swear-by and it looks great, except for some reason on the very last page it is showing three arrows instead of just two: http://www.encapo.com/top/15-organizing-products-on-amazon-that-people-actually-swear-by/5/

Can you tell me how to remove the arrow on the top so there is just an arrow like this “<” next to the arrow button like this “>”?

I have granted wpmu support access , in case that helps.

Thanks for your help!