Supporter broke after "upgrade all blogs" – Live Site, Please Help

I had the Supporter plugin working this morning and then clicked the “upgrade” button which upgraded all blogs in my WPMU.

Now, whenever anyone clicks the “Supporter” link in the left menu the Subscribe with Paypal button does not appear.

Of course, they then click the “multiple blogs” to do the upgrade but get more errors because their primary blog was never upgraded.

What do I need to do to get the subscribe button back on the Supporter.php page in the WPMU admin?