Title | Sitename ...or is it?

In the setup of WPMU DEV SEO I have POST and PAGE setup as: %%title%% | %%sitename%% However, it displays Sitename | Title.

I've tried with several themes. Studio theme Simple SEO is disabled. I disabled Sitemaps and SEO (in case there is a conflict). I'm stumped.

http://sweetaddress.com/about/