trying to restrict access to home page ...

I am using the membership plugin for a site that will be accessible by employees only, there should be no public access to the site. I was having trouble getting them access to the "lost password" page, so I created a new access level for "forgot password" and have given that positive access to the "lost password" page, and that is working, however the home page isn't protected any more. So unauthenticated users are able to get to ...

http://teama1.casterfamily.wpengine.com/

and shouldn't. Users who haven't logged in should only be able to see ...
http://teama1.casterfamily.wpengine.com/login
http://teama1.casterfamily.wpengine.com/lostpassword

Can you help me with configuration? I will update so you have access now.

Thanks!