Twitter & Pinterest Icons Are Coming And Going

I am having some issues with the floating social plugin. I have the comments plus plugin installed as well, so I have tested with the "my site is using scripts from this service" checkbox and still get mixed results. Sometimes the twitter icon and count show up and sometimes it does not, just seems very intermittent.

I have chosen yes to the fix front page compatibility as well. It seems that moving the order in which the different social networks are displayed makes different ones show up and disappear. Sometimes just the word "tweet" appears sometimes nothing at all. After moving the order around, sometimes the pinterest icon drops off. Not sure if I am missing something or if I have some other plugins that are causing compatibility issues here.

I have already granted staff access if somebody would like to take a look from the backend.