Unable To Disable Membership Protection


I had a page that was protected using the Membership2 Pro plugin. I now want to make the page un-protected. I was able to disable the second section of the Membership Access panel on the right of the page, but not the first section. Toggling the first section produces no results.

In the Protected Content settings I see that this page should be accessible to everyone, but it is not. I have attached a couple screenshots for your reference. The page that should now be unprotected is: http://www.jumpropewod.com/protected-content/?redirect_to=http://www.jumpropewod.com/jump-rope-workouts/pro-for-time-workout-1/