Upgrades vs Supporters vs Members Feature / Comparison matrix

Hi there

I've just gone ahead and added these 3 plugins as I thought they should be 'working together'

but having a look at the options ... I probably should only have 1 of these running - but I can't figure out which one is best.

My aim is to have a setup with a monthly recurring fee for 'supporters' and then I want to allow for paid extras like space or premium themes

Can I do all this with just the supporter plugin?

cheers

Damien