Using Membership Plugin. New posts are incorrectly redirecting to "no access page"

If you try to reach any new posts, for example: http://tutuology.com/submit-a-tutorial-or-craft-project/, it is redirecting to my membership no access page. Why is this happening? I have not set the posts to redirect and they should be visible to ALL viewers, strangers, visitors, etc. They are also selected in positive rules so they should be accessible to all.