Video hidden when protection is on

At the bottom of the home page, I have a video slider. When I have Protection On (see attached screenshot Protection), the slider will not play for logged out users and displays a static image( see attached screenshot Static). Alos, when I disable the Membership 2 plugin, the slider works fine. When I turn off protection for the site, the slider works fine. I have all the settings currently set to Everyone so I am not restricting access at all as far as I can tell. I have tested the behavior on multiple computers and browsers. I have granted support access to the site as well.