Weight Rate shipping to the United States doesn't work

I have a site where the client is Canadian and has set up in their weights for Canada and International but United States gets free shipping for some reason. Here is what we have setup in the backend http://prntscr.com/brk6ot.

Some ways I tested it include the following:
- In the back end I tried just putting in Canada and United States as the countries but still on the front end of the website it gives the United States free shipping.
- I changed the Country from Canada and a Canadian address to the United States and an American address and when I went to confirm there was no shipping fees.

Is there something I am missing?