What is wrong with my Avatars installation?

I have installed Avatars plugin on hypeorlando.com and it is working just fine. When I make a copy to hypesouthflorida.com it allows me to upload, crop and save the image but after that it will not show.

When I try to go directly to the image in the uploads/ folder it works fine but when I try to go to the rewrite url it does not. Permalinks are working just fine.

Is it possible that we need to purchase another license for the additional site for the plugin to work?